Both products are mechanical inhalers with no nicotine, no electricity and no liquid. The differences lie in what's included, the materials and the currency: Makya Taste currently costs €59.90, a KLAIR starter kit CHF 69.90 or CHF 79.90. We only compare what can be publicly verified on both sides.
In short
- Neither contains nicotine, and both work mechanically, with no heating and no vapor.
- Makya Taste is on sale for €59.90 instead of €99.90, KLAIR costs CHF 69.90 or CHF 79.90.
- For refills, a Makya pack costs €8.90, a KLAIR pack CHF 6.90. Both contain three pieces.
- Makya states 3 to 5 days per filter, KLAIR 3 to 4 days per capsule.
- We don't rate any health differences. We lack the data for that on both designs.
Why this comparison comes from us and what that means
We make one of the two products ourselves. That is a conflict of interest, and that's why we disclose the rules this article is built on.
We only compare what both companies state publicly: design, what's included, price, refills, availability. All information on Makya comes from the manufacturer's website and is marked as such.
We do not compare health effects, and we do not rate the quality of the other product. Disparaging it would be prohibited under the Swiss Federal Act against Unfair Competition, and it wouldn't be backed by the facts either.
Where Makya is the better choice is covered further down in a section of its own.
Side by side
Information as of September 22, 2026. Prices change, so check them before you buy.
| Criterion | Makya Taste | KLAIR |
|---|---|---|
| Nicotine | none, manufacturer states "100% free of nicotine" | none |
| Tobacco | none | none |
| Electricity, battery, charging | no | no |
| Liquid, vaporizing | no | no |
| Visible vapor | no | no |
| Consumable part | flavor filter | cotton capsule |
| Pieces per pack | 3 filters | 3 capsules |
| Stated duration per piece | 3 to 5 days | 3 to 4 days |
| Refill pack price | €8.90 | CHF 6.90 |
| Kit price | €59.90 instead of €99.90 | CHF 69.90 or CHF 79.90 |
| Included in the kit | device, stainless steel necklace, 3 flavors, cleaning kit, protective case | pen, cleaning kit with cloth and pipe cleaner, 3 refill packs |
| Choice of flavors | 16 on the product range page | 18 |
| Currency and market | euros, also ships to Switzerland | Swiss francs, shipping within Switzerland |
Two notes on the table. The Makya kit price is a sale price; according to the manufacturer's website, the regular price is €99.90. And the prices are in different currencies, more on that in a moment.

What is technically the same
The most important finding of this comparison is something they share, not a difference.
Both products are mechanical inhalers. There is no battery, no heating element and no liquid. When you draw, ambient air flows past a flavored carrier material.
That puts both in the same product category, and this category is technically fundamentally different from e-cigarettes and disposables.
So if you are torn between the two, you are not comparing two concepts, but two versions of the same concept.
The price comparison and its catch
This is where most comparison pages get imprecise.
The prices are in different currencies. Makya prices in euros, we price in francs. A direct comparison of the numbers is therefore not clean, and we deliberately don't convert it here.
What you need to check yourself: the exchange rate on the day you buy, any shipping costs to Switzerland and the import regulations. These points change the final price noticeably.
For ongoing use, the order of magnitude can still be given. At the stated durations, a pack of three lasts nine to fifteen days. Per month, that's around two to three packs on both sides.
Makya's regular kit price is above ours, the sale price below it. Whether the sale is permanent, we don't know.
What's in the kit
The kits are put together differently, and that is a real basis for deciding.
According to the manufacturer's website, Makya includes a stainless steel necklace, a protective case, a cleaning kit, three flavors and a 30-day challenge.
KLAIR includes a pen, a cleaning kit with cloth and pipe cleaner, and three refill packs with three capsules each, so nine capsules.
If you find the necklace and the protective case useful, you get more accessories with Makya. If you want more consumables in the kit, you get nine capsules from us instead of three filter packs.
That is a matter of taste in the literal sense, not a matter of quality.
When Makya is the better choice
We are writing this section on purpose, because a comparison without it wouldn't be one.
If you order from or live in the EU. A euro price with no border in between is simpler than buying abroad with exchange rates and import.
If you want the accessories. The necklace and protective case are included in the Makya kit. With us, the case is a separate item.
If you are missing one of the sixteen Makya flavors. Product ranges differ, and if you are looking for a particular flavor, that's what you decide on.
If you want the longer stated duration. Makya states 3 to 5 days per filter, we state 3 to 4 days per capsule. Both are manufacturer figures, and both vary a lot in practice.
When KLAIR is the better fit
And the other direction, with the same yardsticks.
If you order in Switzerland. Prices in francs, shipping with Swiss Post, no import questions.
If you want a bigger choice of flavors. Our range includes 18 flavors, among them one without any flavor.
If you want more consumables in the starter kit. Nine capsules versus three filter packs.
If the lower refill price matters to you. CHF 6.90 versus €8.90 per pack, with three pieces each.
What we don't do in this comparison
Two things are missing here on purpose, and both are missing for the same reason.
We don't compare health effects. To our knowledge, there are no studies on mechanical aroma inhalers, neither on our design nor on any other. A comparison where both sides are unresearched would not be information.
We don't claim any effect on quitting smoking, for either product.
If you are strongly physically dependent, start at the pharmacy or with counseling. That applies equally to both products.
The key points in brief
Both products are mechanical inhalers with no nicotine, electricity or liquid. Technically, they belong to the same category.
The differences lie in the accessories, the choice of flavors, the refill price and the currency. Factor in the exchange rate, shipping and import before you compare numbers.
We say nothing about health differences, because there is no data for either design.
IQOS and KLAIR compared is covered in a separate article.
The same comparison is also available for Glo.

Sources
- Makya: Makya Taste product page. Price €59.90 instead of €99.90, what's included, filter duration 3 to 5 days, three filters per flavor bag, statement "100% free of nicotine". makya.de (accessed September 22, 2026)
- Makya: Flavors product range page. Pack price €8.90, 16 flavors, one of them a premium flavor at €10.90. makya.de (accessed September 22, 2026)
- Makya: Home page and country selection with Swiss francs. makya.de (accessed September 22, 2026)
- KLAIR: Product range and prices from our own shop. Starter kit CHF 69.90 or CHF 79.90, refill pack CHF 6.90 with three capsules, 18 flavors. klair.ch (accessed September 22, 2026)
- KLAIR: Return and shipping policy. klair.ch (accessed September 22, 2026)
- Fedlex: Federal Act against Unfair Competition (UWG), Art. 3 para. 1 let. e on disparagement. fedlex.admin.ch (accessed August 24, 2026)
- AT Schweiz: Swiss Tobacco Products Act (TabPG). at-schweiz.ch (accessed August 24, 2026)
- stopsmoking.ch: Free phone counseling for quitting smoking, 0848 000 181. stopsmoking.ch (accessed August 24, 2026)




















2 comments
Fati Golaj
Liebe Team Klair
Herzlichen Dank für die schöne Geschenk. Das hat mich von meinem Herzen gefreut und wie Sie Geschenk eingepackt haben und schöne Gestaltung. Das liegt an euer Herzen und Empathie.
Nochmals Vielen Dank! ❤️🤗🍀
Herzliche Grüsse
Fati Golaj
Caroline Bögli
Guten Tag
Bieten Sie günstige Angebote für Wiederverkäufer an? Wir besitzen einen grossen Bahnhofkiosk und hätten Interesse Ihr Produkt anzubieten.
Besten Dank für Ihr Feedback und freundliche Grüsse
Caroline Bögli
Bögli’s Träff Buchs AG
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.